The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration estimates that 8,650 people died in traffic crashes in the first three months of 2024. This shows a decrease of about 3.2% as compared to 8,935 estimated fatalities during the same period in 2023. It cannot be denied that vehicle crashes still cause a lot of legal problems, particularly when lives are lost.
Traffic accidents could be intentional or unintentional, especially if the drivers are reckless. In some cases, drivers may cause accidents, which can be classified as vehicular homicide if it involves intent to harm. Both vehicle homicide and manslaughter have their similarities and differences.
If you are involved in any of these incidents, you have to understand your rights and consult a vehicular homicide attorney or defense attorney near you to know your options.
Understanding the differences between these two can help you in handling your case.
Definition of Vehicular Homicide
Vehicular manslaughter is the act of killing someone with your car while speeding, intoxicated, or ignoring a traffic sign. Committing this action is punishable under the law.
Offenders of vehicular homicide must show that they acted carelessly and without regard for human life. Mistakes or accidents alone are not enough; they must be exceedingly horrible.
Such crimes can result in jail time, fines, and driver’s license suspension. Your actions will determine whether the case is marked as voluntary or involuntary vehicular homicide.
According to https://www.merrittandmerritt.com/, a DUI attorney experienced in vehicular homicide cases might work out a plea deal with the prosecution and negotiate for a reduction in charges or a more lenient sentence, particularly if there’s a lack of strong evidence against the defendant.
Definition of Manslaughter
The intent to kill is the primary difference between vehicular homicide and manslaughter. In manslaughter cases, a person kills without preplanning for such an act, typically in a situation of rage, slip-up, or reckless behavior. This means that killing someone was not planned at all.
Manslaughter is further classified into involuntary and voluntary manslaughter offenses. Voluntary manslaughter refers to killing with intent towards a victim but under extenuating conditions that would render the killer less liable, such as provocation.
Involuntary manslaughter, on the other hand, means unintentional killing resulting from careless actions or crimes of negligence. One example of voluntary manslaughter is shoving someone during a heated argument and that person falls and dies. If you drive carelessly and cause an accident that kills someone, you are guilty of involuntary manslaughter.
Key Differences Between the Two
Understanding the distinctions between vehicular homicide and manslaughter is a key step in comprehending the legal implications of each charge. At their respective cores, these two differ by intent level and the surrounding circumstances for occurrence.
Another key difference lies in the severity of punishment. Punishment for vehicular homicide is harsher than punishment for manslaughter since the former is perceived to be a higher degree of crime compared to the latter.
Legal Consequences and Penalties
If you are charged with vehicular homicide or manslaughter, the legal consequences can be terrifying and life-changing. Each offense has different penalties depending on jurisdiction and the specific circumstances surrounding the incident, as well as your past criminal record.
When charged with vehicular homicide, felony charges may be applied, which can result in prison sentences ranging from several years to life, depending on the severity of the crime and the driver’s intent. Individuals guilty of vehicular homicide are charged with hefty fines, which can cause additional financial strain to the individual.
Meanwhile, manslaughter is a lower crime and has a lighter punishment than felony charges. Manslaughter penalties include years in prison and huge fines. Involuntary manslaughter convictions can negatively impact a person’s career and relationships.
Both offenses may result in driving suspension and treatment program attendance. Talking to a knowledgeable attorney about these issues will help you understand the ramifications of both charges.
Examples of Each Offense
Real-life examples of vehicular homicide and vehicular manslaughter can provide people with a clearer understanding of the prosecution and its factors in determining the outcome of these crimes.
For example, in an incident where one drunk driver crashed into a pedestrian and killed him, the driver was charged with vehicular homicide since his actions were considered reckless. The case shows how intoxication can increase charges against a person.
Assuming the driver was not speeding or driving recklessly, he would face manslaughter and not vehicular homicide because his actions do not show a level of disregard for human life.
The above examples present critical differences between vehicular homicide and vehicular manslaughter situations. In general, a vehicular homicide offense requires a higher level of negligence or intent, whereas manslaughter incidents are mostly unintended consequences of less-than-reckless behavior.
Factors Influencing Charges
The factors determining the severity of charges in vehicular homicide or manslaughter vary from case to case. Driving recklessly or using drugs or alcohol before driving can lead to serious charges.
Another factor that could increase the severity of charges is engaging in a high-speed chase while being pursued by officers.
The victim’s status plays a huge role. If the victim is a child or a pedestrian, the legal consequences may be more serious. Your prior record of driving or vehicle violations could affect the charges that are brought up against you.
Keep in mind that states have varying laws and penalties for both vehicular homicide and manslaughter.
Implications for Victims’ Families
Experiencing a vehicle manslaughter or homicide incident that leads to the death of a close person often leaves the family members emotionally distressed.
This emotional strain, along with other various emotions, can significantly affect you. This complicates everything with regard to court appearances, trials, and plea bargains.
The ongoing costs of funeral bills and medical bills incurred from the injuries, especially when a primary source of income is lost, can also add financial burdens. This financial burden can cause an increase in emotional burden for the bereaved.
The verdict may determine your sense of justice as well. A lenient sentence may frustrate a layman and make one feel that he has been denied justice. A harsh sentence may not provide the closure you want. It can be comforting for you to talk to many people who have similar experiences.
Professional counselling is an important tool that can address the feelings of grief, anger, or betrayal.
Conclusion
The complex nature of both manslaughter and vehicular homicide makes it necessary to seek legal guidance for guidance. Avoid costly mistakes and additional stress by having a skilled attorney handle the legal aspects of your case.
Click here for more information.